Under review
HAL was given two orders that could not both be obeyed
What does the HAL case actually say, and where does the comparison with real systems stop being literal?
Evidence: Documented
Which cultural frame is doing the explaining?
Use a work of fiction to open a real question, then hand the question to the research: what the story asserted, what the field has since demonstrated, and where the comparison stops being literal.
What does the HAL case actually say, and where does the comparison with real systems stop being literal?
Same dimension
What can we decide, and with what evidence?
All formats